So after going through the hell that is California SMOG, I thought to share some of my experiences with you guys.
SMOGGING THE CAR
Stock 1995 BMW M3, 188k miles on motor - new plugs, O2 sensor, and newer intake, timing, etc. sensors. Oil, filter and air filter changed. And YES, the cats were HOT... come on guys, I've been on this board 10 years now...
15 mph: HC 123 (max 85), CO .32 (max .50), NO 833 (max 695)
25 mph: HC 50 (max 50), CO .15 (max .47), NO 492 (max 717)
The main issue here is unburnt fuel (HC) and Nitrous Oxide (NO) which sometimes is the temp of the combustion chamber, but if both the HC and NO are high, the catalytic converter isn't working. In my case, it wasn't converting the unburnt fuel molecules, and was just cooking - hence high NO. Think of a bad cat like a hot boiling fuel soup.
MAGNAFLOW
So Magnaflow makes a California SMOG-approved Catalytic converter - part #36004
It's a universal deal, but the fit and finish is good and it welds up nicely. Magaflow retails the Cats for $410.
For reference - BMW will sell you the ENTIRE CAT system for $2300 retail. OEMBMWParts.com (something like that will sell it to you for $1300). Bavarian Autosport sells DAC CAT Systems for $750-ish.
$1300 wasn't bad for a new stock system. But installation and shipping would add an easy $300 to $400 to that price.
The DAC is a good price, but the warranty of two years sucks. We have smog every 2 years so what's the point of that?
After reading some reviews with Magnaflow on other car boards like Honda and Toyota, I pulled the trigger with another muffler shop near me in Dublin CA. (Scott's Minute Muffler - yelp him. Solid 5 star reviews).
Long story short, Scott got me the cats AND installation for $400 ($429 with tax). Yes, I got parts and labor for less than retail!
Ok so +1.
I drove the car for about 5 days to get a few miles on the cats for SMOG. About 250 miles in my case.
Before my SMOG, I did a 20 mile round trip to make sure all systems were warm. I pulled into the smog shop at 3pm. It was about 67 degrees outside.
Here's the results...
15 mph: HC 59 (max 85), CO .06 (max .50), NO 10 (max 695)
25 mph: HC 22 (max 50), CO .02 (max .47), NO 5 (max 717)
The drops are pretty staggering.
1. The HC's dropped in half - obviously the catalytic converting the unburned fuel.
2. The Carbon Monoxide dropped by 500%+
3. The Nitrous Oxide dropped by 500%+
+2
And for the final bonus...
1. 5-year, 50,000-mile external warranty; 25,000-mile internal warranty
2. Cost $410 retail
3. Performance? Put it this way... my highway torque picked up A LOT.
I had to sell my TRM chip, intake, HFM, and injectors to help finance this replacement (got some monster bills this month), but given that my stock cats weren't flowing as well, installing the Magna ones helps make up that feeling of the power I lost.
In short
I'm pretty stoked. I saved an easy $800 over the best price I could find over the stock system, got back some lost power, and passed smog with numbers only new cars see.